Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Waitlisted: The unacceptable standard of mental health care in Canada

While aimlessly scrolling through my Twitter newsfeed at 3:15 in the morning, I saw a story which triggered my "ranting phase", so this will be an "opinion" piece, which I seem to do many of actually.  

The article, entitled "Teen waiting over 18 months for psychiatry appointment", published by CBC Saskatchewan, this in-depth article immediately struck a chord with me. Mainly because I have found myself to be in a similar position two years ago. As I continued to scroll through the article, I found myself becoming more enraged, simply at the fact that the health care system was clearly neglecting the needs of a 15-year old girl, who is in need of mental health counselling. Just like the same was done to me at the time.


An infographic outlining the inefficiency of the Canadian [mental]health care system. To me, these statistics appear to be grossly inflated.




This is an unacceptable standard of mental health care. I can feel this young girl's pain, as I was her. When I was 17, I was admitted to CHEO for suicidal ideations and extreme depression. While I was there they diagnosed me with Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), Social/Generalized Anxiety Disorder, Panic Disorder and OCD (which I had suffered from since I was about 11 years old). 

I spent approximately 2 months and once I was finally released they put me on a waiting list for a team of mental heath professionals at the Royal Ottawa (because I was almost 18, which seemed to be quite a big issue with them in terms of treatment options).

I started school again and continued to wait, and wait. 

Graduation came along, and so did more waiting. 

September, university, a huge transition in one's young life then crept up on me, and yet I still eagerly waited for that phone call. 

Then around November/December, my depression got worse and I slowly felt myself falling back down the rabbit hole again. The isolation, the overwhelming sadness, the thoughts of dying. Everything was crumbing around me and I had no one to help me (except for my parents who were over 4 hours away). During that time I went through a lot, my anxiety spiked due to the new changes and people, a relationship (which didn't go over so well; lying, abuse, staking, ect...), grades dropping like bombs in the sky. I informed the doctor I was seeing at the time about my depression and suicidal/self harm ideations, and they referred me to their psychiatrist. This didn't prove to be any better. All they did was put me on new medications, which made me feel even worse (without even consulting with my family physician about my medical history) and later told me that they had a five visit policy, meaning that you could only receive five hours of counselling throughout the school year. I ended up seeking the help of the crisis counsellor at the university, however all they did was tell me to call the crisis hotline. Now, for someone with severe anxiety issues, talking on the phone is a huge trigger (at least for myself, I cannot speak for others.) It makes the feelings even worse, so at that point it's better off suffering in silence.

In March I had to move back home (and drop out of university) due to health issues and because my family and friends became extremely worried about me due to the fact that I cut off communication and had not been heard from in months (to the point where they were making public pleas for me to come home). At that moment, we all realized that something needed to be done (for good). 

During that time, I was seeing a psychologist with the clinic I went to. However, they abruptly informed me seconds after walking out of a session that I was no longer eligible to receive treatment, due to the fact that my family doctor transferred clinics. At that point my doctor took the initiative to make the call to inform them that I was in crisis again. 

16 months it took to finally receive that phone call. Too long in my opinion. No one should have to wait that long for mental health care. Megan and myself are only a fraction of people suffering through the same ordeal. The rise in suicide rates across Canada just confirms this. 

Mental health is an extremely important issue, just as important as one's own physical health. More important than the millions of dollars the government spends on tearing up and rebuilding (nearly) perfectly functional streets, cutting thousands of public sector jobs and building environmentally harmful pipelines (big priorities indeed.)

Now I don't consider myself a political person, in fact I don't even follow politics, but when it comes to issues like these, it even ruffles my feathers. Even an average citizen like myself can see how wrong this is. 18 months, how long this young girl has suffered with mental health issues. You wouldn't make a patient suffering from a stroke wait that long, or a heart transplant patient wait for a functioning organ essential to sustain their's and human life (oh wait, yes we would...) There's the Canadian health care system for you ladies and gentlemen! It's free, but only if you live long enough to see a doctor...

One of my inspirations for wanting to become a psychologist is because of this very issue. I have lived it and have been a member of this corrupted system. I want to do something to fix this unacceptable standard of health care, especially relating to mental health. By adding one more registered psychologist to a team, it can help dozens of patients in need. Think about that for a minute. Now, if only the federal (and provincial) governments would have this same realization and think about making changes to the system. 

Now, this article focuses specifically on Saskatchewan's issue with wait listing, however I see the same problem in Ontario. In fact, this problem is most likely occurring across the nation. In fact, I know it is. 

People become so desperate or so ill that they get to the point where they lose control. They represent it in many ways, but the most common seems to be suicide (a solemn and pointless act, when putting it into perspective, considering our claim of having "one of the best health care systems in the world") 

Others take it out externally, on the public. Now I make it extremely clear, I am not one of those people who believe that mentally ill individuals are responsible for crimes. The Greyhound bus decapitation and most recently, the Moncton shootings were cases in which the accused called upon "the defence of mental disorder", therefore deeming them "not criminally responsible (NCR)" for their crimes. Now, these are clearly a fraction of these criminal cases, and are not reflective of the link between mental illness and crime as a whole. However upon reflection, perhaps if these individuals were given proper treatment, those crimes could have been avoided. 


When one steps back and looks at the whole picture, it makes you think about the relative simplicity of the potential solution of this issue. What is it? Well, it's a collection of simplistic ideas combined into a prospectively successful aggregation/collective:

- Address the issue, don't deny it
- Increase the number and encourage the enrolment of mental health workers in Canada
- Decrease wait times (resulting from the above point)
- Provide immediate crisis counselling for patients waiting for a permanent psychologist/psychiatrist
- Remove the "10-session policy", because this results in a never-ending circle of crisis
- Enforce stricter procedures regarding crisis intervention and patient care (referring to the recent suicide at the Civic hospital in Ottawa)


These are just some of the ideas I came up with within the span of 30 seconds, so I'm sure the individuals in charge of these issues can come up with even more, and enforce them (if the motivation and attention is brought to the issue) 

News media is just the start, but in a world of technological innovation and impassioned individuals, I am hopeful that we, as a collective society, can do something to solve this issue and draw the government's attention to these matters. Matters which are important to the smooth functioning of a cogent nation as well as to the well-being of its citizens.



You can find the original story here.

Friday, June 6, 2014

Kidnapped in Afghanistan: A Personal Viewpoint

During my time as an amateur journalist, I have come across many news stories and written about many social issues. However, I cannot help but to become involved in this story which has been at the centre of media attention and debate.

The focus of news media lately has been regarding the story of a Canadian and American couple who were kidnapped in the Warsaw province of Afghanistan approximately 20 months ago.


That couple happens to be my cousin Josh, and his wife Caitlan along with their baby.


The quiet couple are now the center of media attention after videos were released of them pleading for help from their governments. However, it seems like it might not be all that big of a priority for government heads rescuing their own Canadian and American citizens from the hands of terrorist groups such as the Taliban. 


This was the case involving Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, an army sergeant who was recently released from captivity of the Taliban in exchange for five high level Taliban members. However, as I later learned, Josh and Caitlan were supposed to be a part of that deal in the first place. So, what happened? Although both families kept the videos private, they decided to make them public, in hopes that the publicity surrounding the Bergdahl case would draw attention to Josh and Caitlan's situation.  I (along with my family) were disappointed that Josh and Caitlan were not freed.


Regarding the US' regulations on hostage negotiations, Rep. Duncan Hunter of the House Armed Services Committee questioned the reasoning of it all by asking "Instead of five for one, why not five for five?" My point exactly!


The constant bickering between the committees and individuals responsible for the well-being of Canadian and American hostages in foreign countries, makes me question the competency and effectiveness of the Canadian and American governments (as well as all parties involved in the process).

My uncle recently said in an interview with Global News: "It would be no more appropriate to have our government turn their backs on their citizens than to turn their backs on those who serve," and for once I agree with him. All lives should be treated as equally valuable and we should do everything in our power to preserve them. No matter what the background of the person has to reveal about their lives. In all honestly, their story has been clouded by the misconceptions of society. Their passion for travel and multiculturalism has been overlooked by the fact that they were exploring in hostile territory (which caused uproar among the public.) And Josh's previous ties to the Khadr family has sparked controversy regarding the decision to rescue both of them from the hands of the Taliban, bringing me to my other point. 


For all of those individuals posting vulgar comments regarding Josh and Caitlain like "I pray for their deaths" and describing them as "Taliban loving tourists", well, unless you know them personally and I know for a fact that both of them are kind, generous people who simply wanted to help others in need. I do get offended when people speak ill my family and I'm sure that anyone else would feel the same if the same thing was done to them. It is easy to hide behind a computer screen and spread hateful comments, without fearing that anyone could see your face. However for families (including myself), hearing those words hurts more than you can imagine. You should never judge a person unless you have walked a million miles in there shoes and understand the challenges they face on a daily basis.


In all honesty, all I want is to see my cousin again. I miss him, and watching those videos haunt me, as now, I don't even recognize the once giant teddy bear who used to comfort me and protect me as his younger cousin.  I have missed so many memories with him, memories which leave a feeling of emptiness inside me: my graduation, my (and his) grandmother's funeral and numerous holidays. Occasions which revolve around the comfort of family. Every time we get together as a family, there is always an empty void from where Josh would be sitting beside us. That void will be forever with us, until Josh and Caitlan come home with their baby, ready to start their lives anew. 



I miss you Josh and pray for your safe return home. 









The videos released of my cousin and his wife pleading for help from their governments

Videos of my aunt and uncle along with the Coleman family speaking out about the issue

Updates regarding Josh and Caitlan's situation